Bainbridge Island Real Estate Market Report: September 2026

5

BAINBRIDGE BUYERS BUCK THE LOCAL TREND 

The Northwest MLS Sales are down, but BI is up

We all know the most classic expression in the real estate industry is “location, location, location.” When it comes to understanding the “real estate market,” then, it’s imperative to focus on the specific location in question. For over ten years I’ve been analyzing the monthly statistics of the Bainbridge Island real estate market, and what never ceases to amaze me is how there is always some nugget of data that jumps off the spreadsheet.

I don’t have to tell you that we’re living in uncertain times, and I don’t mean whether or not the ferry is going to sail today 😉!

However, despite the laundry list of reasons for consumers not to buy a house, from stubbornly high prices amid talk of a coming recession (the average sale price on the island is +3.3% year-to-date), interest rates back up over 7% (around a point higher than a year ago), to the high price of everything else in a household budget, not to mention fears of job security… somehow Bainbridge Island remained insulated from those headwinds last month.

In September we saw the strongest number of closed sales for the month (42) since September of 2021, a figure much higher than the average seen in the three years prior to 2020. And these 42 sales were an astounding 35% increase from August; conversely, the entire NWMLS saw a decrease of 4% month-over-month in closed sales in September. So while the entire Northwest MLS sales activity was down, BI was up.

We also saw the strongest number of pending sales (33) on record for the month, a figure 10% higher than the average seen in the three years prior to 2020. This leads me to believe the trend of strong closed sales will continue into October, setting up a strong finish for the year.

Speaking of the year, the 426 new listings year-to-date is the highest since 2018 and is roughly on pace with the three-year pre-pandemic average of 439. And the 248 closed sales year-to-date is the highest since the 301 seen in 2021, but still 21% less than the three-year pre-pandemic average. So while we are back to normal on supply for the “before Covid” times, we are down about 20% on the demand side in that same timeframe.

What does this all mean for the active buyers and sellers right now? When people ask me how the market is doing, I’m responding with “stable.” Prices are holding, sellers are listing, buyers are buying, and the appeal to owning property on the island has not blown away in the headwinds.

Want to hear more about September's summer blowout? Please check out my Bainbridge Market Report below to read all of the month’s metrics and trends.

Thanks,

Jason

P.S. Sharing the love of some clients

TESTIMONIAL 

I had a great experience working with Jason from expectation-setting to closing. He kept me informed throughout the process and consistently followed through on every one of his steps. His professional yet personable demeanor reflected his confidence and put me at ease. I also appreciate his regular newsletters through which he gives his personal take on local conditions. That tells me he is staying in touch with current and ever-changing market conditions. Some agents just grab and publish canned material in order to keep streaming. It doesn't hurt that he has a good sense of humor. I'm happy to recommend Jason.

  • Jon Rose, Shepard Way

September's Sales

Are you curious what a property sold last month? Click the links below to view the sold listings in my Multiple Listing Service "Portal" and see sale prices for every property sold on Bainbridge Island in September.

If you would like, I can sign you up for an auto search so you can follow a specific niche of the market.

 

Single Family Homes Sales

 

Condo Sales

 

Vacant Land Sales(opens in new tab)

Non-profit corner: 

Every child deserves the opportunity to participate, belong and succeed.

I’m proud to support the YES Fund (Youth Experience Fund), which helps Bainbridge Island students take part in school activities, sports and enrichment opportunities.

In just a few years, the YES Fund has helped hundreds of local youth with everything from sports uniforms and graduation gowns to enrichment programs. Sometimes a relatively small amount can make a very big difference.

Learn more about the YES Fund and how you also can help support our local youth: CLICK HERE 

Jason is perfect for real estate because he understands people and how to help them through difficult situations.
— Jim and Trish Corsetti

My goal is to serve your needs; I will move mountains to ensure you meet your objectives, listen carefully so I can focus on your motivations, and provide you with the insight you need to make strategic decisions. I'm here to get your job done, so please let me know what I can do for you or those you know.

JS_headshot3_square_small